I believe petco just modified their recipe for their WholeHearted line, no gums or carrageenan. The tops on the label are white. A top quality recipe that really deserves the 5 stars it gained within our review when remaining cost-effective for pet entrepreneurs. Launched in 2008 The Pet Food Advisor https://milocksxd.thechapblog.com/34746523/details-fiction-and-pet-shops-in-mirdif